How judging works
Every entry is judged on the same published rubric, by team code, without names or schools.
The process
-
Checks. Within 24 hours of each entry, we check format and eligibility only.
-
Judges. Only external judges score. They may include founders, investors, bankers and business lecturers. Each judge fills in a conflict-of-interest form, and a judge with any connection to a team does not score it.
-
Online round, Sunday 7 to Tuesday 23 February 2027. At least 2 judges score each entry on their own, by team code, on the published criteria.
-
Review. Where two judges’ totals for an entry are 20 or more marks apart, they talk it through.
-
Results. Every team gets its result by email on Sunday 28 February 2027. The number of finalists depends on how many teams submit: up to 10 finalists plus 1 reserve team if 30 or more teams submit; 8 if 20 to 29 submit; 6 if fewer than 20.
-
The final. A panel of three judges scores each team, with one reserve judge. Scores start from zero. If two teams tie, the higher Innovation score wins; if they are still tied, the judges decide together. Finalists receive written feedback from the judges.
The rubric (100 marks)
- 15 Problem understanding
- 20 Innovation
- 15 Market and customer evidence
- 25 Business model and financial viability
- 15 Scalability and impact
- 10 Communication
- 15 Problem understanding
- 20 Innovation
- 15 Market and customer evidence
- 20 Business model and financial viability
- 10 Scalability and impact
- 10 Pitch delivery
- 10 Answers to questions
Scroll sideways to see the whole table
| Criterion | What judges look for | Online | Final |
|---|---|---|---|
| Problem understanding | A real problem, who has it, and how the team knows | 15 | 15 |
| Innovation | How new the idea is, and why it beats what already exists | 20 | 20 |
| Market and customer evidence | Customers spoken to, real data, cited sources | 15 | 15 |
| Business model and financial viability | How it makes money, realistic costs and prices, whether the team can run it | 25 | 20 |
| Scalability and impact | Room to grow beyond the first customers; value to people and the community | 15 | 10 |
| Communication | A clear video and plan, strong visuals | 10 | Not scored |
| Pitch delivery | Clear, confident, on time | Not scored | 10 |
| Answers to questions | Knows the business and handles challenges well | Not scored | 10 |
| Total | 100 | 100 | |
Score bands
| Band | Share of the marks | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Excellent | 85 to 100% | Clear, specific and convincing; little to improve |
| Good | 60 to 84% | Solid, with a few gaps |
| Developing | 30 to 59% | Partly there; key parts missing or vague |
| Weak | 0 to 29% | Missing, unclear or unconvincing |
Example, Innovation (20 marks): 17 to 20 is clearly new and explains why it beats existing options; 12 to 16 is a clear improvement on an existing idea; 6 to 11 is an existing idea with small changes; 0 to 5 copies something that already exists.
Keeping it fair
- Team codes only: no names, schools, logos or uniforms.
- Judges declare anyone they know and do not score that team.
- Members of Bithra’s Events team do not compete.
- At the final, judges score each team straight after its pitch.
The judges’ decisions are final.